This article will help you quickly compare and evaluate the best QA automation tools for quality assurance testing.
QA automation testing is just what it sounds like…quality assurance for apps and software through mobile testing and web testing, but automated. What does this mean? There are QA automation tools available that can take over repetitive tasks in order to free up your team’s time to do more complex or more creative problem-solving. Make no mistake, there is no way to achieve 100% automated testing (we wish!) but automation tools can help take the mundane stuff off your plate during day-to-day operations.
The Automation Testing Life Cycle (ATLC) will generally guide you through the process of automated testing, starting with decision making and selecting appropriate tools and ending with a review and assessment of the whole process. As mentioned, the first step is always selecting the right tools. That’s where this article comes in.
In this post, I’ll explain what test automation can do for you and how it can help your efforts with quality assurance for software development. I’ll share with you a few of the best automation testing tools on the market and briefly highlight each item.
Compare & Evaluate The 10 Best Automation Testing QA tools
I’ve selected a handful of QA tools that specialize in automation. Take a look at what I’ve compiled here.
The Best QA Tool List
Here’s a shortlist of the best test automation tools:
Have some questions about QA automation? Browse through this section first.
What Is QA Automation?
Quality assurance (QA) is often done manually; however, there is software designed to take the load off of human participants and reduce manual testing. QA automation is done through software designed to explore, test, and report on its subject. Test automation will often apply artificial intelligence and machine learning (AI/ML) to better service tasks for test optimization, intelligent test generation, execution, and reporting.
What Are The Benefits Of Automated Testing?
Automated testing can help speed up the process of delivering quality software faster, known as “Quality at Speed” (QaS) or sometimes “Quality at Scale“. Automated testing is an important component of DevOps toolchains and agile methodologies, which helps deliver on QaS. Mobile automation testing tools can:
increase feedback speeds
lower business expenses (hourly wages)
increase test efficiency and scope
detect defects earlier on in the development process
generate more thorough test results
Automated testing is also often an important part of software development that uses a continuous integration methodology.
QA Test Tools Comparison Criteria
What are we looking for when we select a QA test tool for review? Here’s a summary of my evaluation criteria:
User Interface (UI): Is it clean and attractive?
Usability: Is it easy to learn and master? Is there good tech support, user support, tutorials, and training? What level of programming skills does the software require?
Features & Functionality:
Documentation: Every QA tool should have a clean, robust documentation process with easily searchable and exportable test results.
Script languages: Does the software work with a variety of popular scripting languages? Or, does it specialize in one script language and go above and beyond in that focus?
Version control: Can testing be done on different files at the same time? Is there a way to show the data history and revert local changes if needed?
Test Commands: Does the software support a large number of test commands? Can test commands be easily added or changed as needed?
Test Scenarios: Does the software support a variety of test scenarios, including performance testing?
Integrations: Is it easy to connect with other tools or plugins? Any pre-built integrations? Does it integrate with any bug tracking tools, such as JIRA? Does it support various operating systems and browsers, including Internet Explorer, Google Chrome, Safari, Firefox, and others?
Value for $: How appropriate is the price for the features, capabilities, and use case? Is pricing clear, transparent, and flexible?
The QA Lead is reader-supported. When you click through links on our site, we may earn a commission.
Overviews Of The Automated Testing Tools
Here’s a brief description of each of the testing automation tools that are featured on this top 10 list.
LambdaTest takes away all the pain points of managing and maintaining an in-house Selenium infrastructure with an online Selenium Grid which is always ready to fire up your test scripts. The tool’s Selenium Grid is equipped with the latest and legacy browsers and operating systems, so you don’t waste time keeping track of what’s new. You can also test locally hosted web applications.
LambdaTest offers more robust reporting options than Selenium, as well as detailed automation test logs to help you quickly debug your Selenium scripts. These logs include exception logs, command logs, network logs, raw Selenium logs, and metadata. You also get a video recording of your entire script execution, along with command by command screenshots. You can also extract Selenium reports using their RESTful Selenium API.
LambdaTest also offers integrations with multiple third-party tools for CI CD, project management, codeless automation, and more to help you fast track your go-to market launch.
Cons to note would be that they don’t offer native app testing yet. Also, for mobile web automation they offer official emulators instead of real devices.
LambdaTest’s automation plan starts from $99/ user/month and offers 100 automation testing minutes free along with lifetime access to the product. You also get 60 mins/month for manual testing which is renewed every month. Offers complimentary access to LT browser.
Selenium automates browsers primarily for automating web applications for testing purposes. This tool offers browser-based automation suites and tests for regression testing, quick bug reproduction scripts, and the ability to manage multiple environments from a central point. Selenium WebDriver also allows for cross-browser testing. Selenium supports a variety of programming languages including Java, C#, Python, Groovy, and Ruby.
Being free to use, Selenium scores well in our Value for Cost evaluation criteria section. Not only is it free but it is feature-rich and open source, so you won’t feel like you’re using a lesser tool.
The default reports are not as smart as they could be, often requiring a lot of manual input to make them worthwhile. Additionally, a con of the tool is that it is only for web-based applications.
Selenium is free to use but offers Sponsorship options for those who want to support the platform.
3. Squish – Best for testing graphical user interfaces (GUIs) and human machine interfaces (HMIs).
The Squish GUI testing tool, a 100% cross-platform tool, comes with a range of features, such as reliable object identification and verification independent of screen layouts, resolution and rendering, a powerful IDE, support for several script languages, and remote testing. It also supports behavior-driven development (BDD) and testing.
One con: Some improvements could be made in end-user training and technical support for this tool. For example, open up technical support communication to video calls, etc., rather than email only.
TestingWhiz offers 300+ commands, integration with bug tracking tools and test management tools, an inbuilt job scheduler with trends, continuous server integration, risk-based testing, image comparison, and data cleansing and comparison.
TestingWhiz is very easy to use, which is why it scores well in our Usability category within the evaluation criteria. Compared to others on this list, the learning curve is quite short.
A few cons to note would be that it is only for Windows and does not offer desktop automation. Additionally, a dedicated mobile recorder would be welcome to better document and play-back test case scenarios.
TestingWhiz starts at $149/user/month and has a free 30-day trial and a free demo.
5. Watir – Best for easily maintaining test cases.
Watir stands for “Web Application Testing in Ruby” and is a testing framework that is constantly updating features and functions; some of the most recent additions include extensive scrolling functionality, new element methods, and an Element Location overhaul.
Watir is great for its ease of maintaining test cases and providing a robust API. This scored it well in Features & Functions as well as Integrations in the evaluation criteria section.
The major con for this tool is that it doesn’t have as large of a community around it as, say, Selenium, which works similarly. Thus, finding an expert in Watir or help in community forums is more difficult.
Watir offers pricing upon request and has a free demo.
6. Testim – Best for automated testing with artificial intelligence.
Testim empowers users to author stable customized tests—either codeless or coded, use artificial intelligence to make tests resilient, run parallel tests across browser types on their test cloud, and create and publish informative bug reports.
Testim caters to both beginner and advanced users, allowing even non-technical team members to create code-free tests. Excellent customer service further enhances the Usability score per our evaluation criteria above.
The major con is that image verification (pixel level validation) is not a local feature, meaning you have to employ a 3rd party solution in order to gain access to this function.
Testim starts at $450/month and has a freemium version with 1000 runs per month.
7. AppliTools – Best for test scenarios involving visual testing.
AppliTools is designed to automatically run functional and visual tests at scale across every app, browser, OS, and screen size. Users can capture visual differences via full-page screenshots, compare visual differences across every platform, and run functional and visual tests.
For a testing tool, AppliTools has a clean and aesthetically pleasing user interface. Boxes and panels keep projects and tests looking highly organized, scoring them well in the UX segment of the above evaluation criteria.
Applitools was built to visually test pages, resulting in false positives due to the fact that it is testing at the page-level in a componentized app. A con is that some time may be required to sift through these results.
AppliTools offers pricing upon request and has a free version for 1 user.
Named a 2020 Gartner Peer Insights Customers’ Choice, Katalon Studio is a complete test automation solution for web automation, mobile, API, and desktop app testing. Katalon Studio revolutionizes the use of open-source frameworks by eliminating the technical complexities, allowing testers to set up, create, run, report, and manage automated tests effectively.
The tool provides both codeless test creation for novices as well as endless script extension and customization for experts. Users can easily generate and execute tests on different OSs (Mac OS, Windows, and Linux), most common browsers, and devices.
Katalon Studio offers a host of integrations for multiple purposes: SDLC and CI/CD management, team collaboration, and many more. It also supports Cucumber, a BDD focused software that allows for test scenarios to be written in plain language. Katalon is also expanding their partnerships — to provide a comprehensive testing experience to its users.
Katalon Studio lost a few points in its user guide and tutorials. Although there is resourceful documentation, it is not well-organized. Users can leverage the community and forum activity to seek help relating to the software.
Katalon Studio starts at $759 for an enterprise license and offers a free version for individual testers.
Telerik Studio is designed to build automated tests for the most current technologies (Angular, React, WPF, MVC, Ajax, RESTful, etc.), build and continuously execute mobile tests for iOS and Android, and take advantage of support for Telerik UI controls and Kendo UI widgets.
Telerik Studio is easy to use with point-and-click functionality, an inviting user interface, and robust documentation. You can also pay an extra fee to the tool consultants in order for them to build a custom framework for you, which is well worth it for many.
However, the software is quite expensive, which may be a barrier to entry for many users and teams. Thus, they lost a few points in the Value for Cost segment of the evaluation criteria.
Telerik Studio starts at $2,499 for a perpetual license and has a free trial and a free demo.
UFT One is designed to accelerate the end-to-end testing of 200+ enterprise apps, technologies, and environments, including web, desktop, mobile, Delphi, SAP, Apache Flex, Java, Oracle, and many more. Users can build and automate tests with AI-based capabilities and intelligent test automation for greater DevOps productivity and resilience. UFT can also be used for business process testing.
UFT One scored well in Usability, as it uses Visual Basic script (VB script) as opposed to a high-level programming language. Furthermore, the tool supports all automation frameworks: keyword driven testing, data-driven testing, modular, and hybrid approaches.
Their source control could use some work, although it did improve a bit when GIT integration was introduced. Additionally, it was quite difficult to set up mobile app integration.
Unified Functional Testing (UFT One) starts at $8000 for a license and has a free trial.
11. Sahi Pro – Best for automatic reporting and bug logging.
Sahi Pro is an automation tool for all technologies: cross-browser web apps, desktop applications, Java applets, web services, and mobile applications. Identify elements, perform mouse and keyboard actions, and work from databases and files.
Sahi Pro is relatively affordable compared to other paid options on this list. Their transparent pricing and generous free trial offering scored them well in the Value for Cost section of the evaluation criteria.
The look and feel of the software’s UX is clunky and a bit outdated. Even from the included screenshot provided here, you can see that certain elements are a bit of an eyesore.
Sahi Pro starts at $695/year and has a free 30-day trial and a free demo.
Other QA Tester Tools Options
Here’s a few more that didn’t make the top list. If you need additional suggestions for a handy QA testing tool, check these out.
Mabl — A unified DevTestOps platform to run automated functional UI tests to check user experience, visual design, and performance.
Appium — An open-source test automation framework for use with native, hybrid, and mobile web apps.
Parasoft — Automated software testing with integrating static and runtime analysis; unit, functional, and API testing; and service virtualization.